City of Elgin, Illinois. She stated that this is not just a policy question, but it is about
protecting the tax payers of Kane County. She explained that Tax Increment Financing
(TIF) was created to help blighted areas redevelop. The idea of a TIF is to free the tax
base and let new revenue fund improvements in the area. Mehr stated that for 23
years, schools, libraries, the County, and the Forest Preserve have not received a dime
of the increased revenue. All the revenue was put into a special fund controlled by the
City of Elgin. Mehr addressed the 23-year TIF cost to the County. She explained that
the TIF has diverted approximately $17M in property tax revenue from the Count and
all taxing bodies. Kane County and the Kane County Forest Preserve have lost $8M to
$9M. Mehr noted that these numbers were based on conservative estimates from city
published projects costs and that the actual loss to local services could be much
greater. She suggested that the Committee receive the exact number from the City of
Elgin on the actual loss to the County. Now, the City of Elgin is requesting support for
another 12 year TIF, in which the County could lose another $4.6M and the Forest
Preserve and pension funds could lose $1.9M. Mehr stated that the Elgin School
District is estimated to lose about $13M in future revenue. The excuse given was more
time was needed and that TIF supporters were robbed of time due to the COVID
Pandemic and the 2008 recession. However, every government body has weathered
these same economic cycles, but did not get to freeze tax revenue and redirect it into
closed door development deals. Mehr stated that if Elgin could not deliver in 23 years,
they do not need 12 more years. They must face the same fiscal reality that all of Kane
County has. Mehr questioned the timing of this TIF extension. She stated that Madam
Chairman Pierog's builidng proposals, such as the new Health Department facility,
were shut down when the $30M County budget shortfall was exposed. However, Pierog
is still tied to campaign donors and constructions and development. These are the
same interests that stand to gain from the extended TIF. Mehr stated that supporting
the Elgin TIF extension, Pierog would earn political favor for future campaign
contributions. She asked the Committee to oppose the letter of support of 12-year TIF
extension.
Yvonne Dinwiddie, Batavia, stated it would take her much longer than the three allotted
minutes to explain the downside of TIFs. She explained that she has attended several
review board meetings and council meetings to establish TIFs, and the downsides are
never presented. She stated that TIF promoters bank on the lack of knowledge about
TIFs and the fact that most people in power do not do their adequate research to ask
the important questions that would expose the flaws in the TIF sale pitches. Dinwiddie
stated that the accumulated effect on multiple TIFs across the County and close
municipalities faced huge losses of critical tax dollars to schools, parks, roads, and
other taxing bodies that must be made up with higher taxes on all properties. This
amounts to billions of dollars. Dinwiddie explained that Kane County has threatened to
cut services due to budget shortages. However, the budget deficiency could be solved
by not having 34 TIF districts. The TIF promoters claim that property values declined
for nine years due to a recession, but everyone lived through it. Dinwiddie stated that
TIF promoters do not disclose is that at the end of the 23 years, all taxable property is
included on the tax rolls as new property, which means a substantial windfall of taxes is
provided. She explained that tax payers do not get to vote on any properties and/or
development within the TIF districts and that the P-TELL is ignored. She stated that
TIFs have been dubbed the largest money laundering scheme of the century. It is
corporate welfare with fraud, waste, and abuse of tax payer dollars. She urged the